Currently submitted to: Journal of Participatory Medicine
Date Submitted: Sep 15, 2026
Open Peer Review Period: Sep 23, 2026 - Nov 18, 2026
(closed for review but you can still tweet)
NOTE: This is an unreviewed Preprint
Warning: This is a unreviewed preprint (What is a preprint?). Readers are warned that the document has not been peer-reviewed by expert/patient reviewers or an academic editor, may contain misleading claims, and is likely to undergo changes before final publication, if accepted, or may have been rejected/withdrawn (a note "no longer under consideration" will appear above).
Peer review me: Readers with interest and expertise are encouraged to sign up as peer-reviewer, if the paper is within an open peer-review period (in this case, a "Peer Review Me" button to sign up as reviewer is displayed above). All preprints currently open for review are listed here. Outside of the formal open peer-review period we encourage you to tweet about the preprint.
Citation: Please cite this preprint only for review purposes or for grant applications and CVs (if you are the author).
Final version: If our system detects a final peer-reviewed "version of record" (VoR) published in any journal, a link to that VoR will appear below. Readers are then encourage to cite the VoR instead of this preprint.
Settings: If you are the author, you can login and change the preprint display settings, but the preprint URL/DOI is supposed to be stable and citable, so it should not be removed once posted.
Submit: To post your own preprint, simply submit to any JMIR journal, and choose the appropriate settings to expose your submitted version as preprint.
Warning: This is an author submission that is not peer-reviewed or edited. Preprints - unless they show as "accepted" - should not be relied on to guide clinical practice or health-related behavior and should not be reported in news media as established information.
Implementing a citizen-based ethics committee for health data governance in Belgium: A realist evaluation
ABSTRACT
Background:
The increasing reuse of personal health data raises ethical questions about who may access such data and who should participate in these decisions. European policy initiatives increasingly emphasize stronger citizen involvement in health data governance, yet in practice citizen participation often remains limited to being informed or consulted. Deliberative approaches, in which citizens actively weigh values and contribute to collective judgments on public benefit data use, offer an alternative, but their application to the ethical assessment of health data access requests remains underexplored, and it is unclear how such arrangements function in practice. To address this gap, a citizen-based ethics committee was piloted within the We Are initiative in Flanders, Belgium, in which citizens themselves collectively undertook the ethical assessment of health data access requests.
Objective:
This study aimed to explain how, why, and under which conditions a citizen-based ethics committee functions as a governance model for public-benefit-based decision-making regarding health data access requests.
Methods:
A qualitative realist evaluation of this pilot was conducted. Seven citizens completed preparatory materials and assessed three real-world health data access requests using an ethical scoring matrix, first individually and then through deliberation across two live committee sessions, with the possibility to revise their assessments. Data included session transcripts, observation notes, and pre- and post-deliberation scores. Analysis followed a retroductive approach, identifying and refining context-mechanism-outcome (CMO) configurations to explain how the committee functioned under different conditions.
Results:
The evaluation resulted in five CMO configurations explaining how the committee functioned under different contextual conditions. Citizens were able to assess the requests substantively and reach a collective decision on each case when they were supported by preparatory materials and a structured framework, and when the information provided was complete, credible, and verifiable. Deliberation triggered deliberative learning: participants engaged with one another’s arguments and reconsidered, refined, or recalibrated their judgments. Inclusion-related perspectives emerged not only through a link worker but through the diversity of viewpoints within the group. Participants valued forming independent judgments before deliberation and engaging without pressure to conform and experienced their participation as most meaningful when they believed their concerns and recommendations would influence decisions and be acted upon.
Conclusions:
A citizen-based ethics committee can operationalize meaningful citizen participation in health data governance, enabling citizens to take up a substantive rather than tokenistic role in ethical decision-making about health data access requests. Meaningful participation depended not only on preparing participants but also on complete, credible, and verifiable case information, a broad diversity of viewpoints, and a deliberative process experienced as fair and impactful. As a small-scale pilot without formal consequences for data access decisions, the study is an exploratory first step whose findings require further testing with other participants and data access requests.
Citation
Request queued. Please wait while the file is being generated. It may take some time.
Copyright
© The authors. All rights reserved. This is a privileged document currently under peer-review/community review (or an accepted/rejected manuscript). Authors have provided JMIR Publications with an exclusive license to publish this preprint on it's website for review and ahead-of-print citation purposes only. While the final peer-reviewed paper may be licensed under a cc-by license on publication, at this stage authors and publisher expressively prohibit redistribution of this draft paper other than for review purposes.